ai for all

Welcome

 ai For government employees

The use of AI in government can have a transformative impact across several areas:

 1. Increased Efficiency

   AI can automate repetitive tasks, such as data processing, document handling, and customer service inquiries, freeing up human workers for more complex tasks. This can reduce operational costs and improve productivity in various government departments.

 2. Improved Decision-Making

   AI-powered tools can analyze vast amounts of data quickly, providing insights that help policymakers make more informed, data-driven decisions. This can lead to better resource allocation, enhanced policy outcomes, and a more proactive approach to addressing public needs.

 3. Enhanced Public Services

   AI can streamline citizen services by providing faster, more accurate responses to inquiries, automating application processes, and improving service delivery through predictive analytics. Chatbots and virtual assistants can reduce wait times and improve the accessibility of government services.

 4. Better Fraud Detection and Security

   AI systems can enhance the detection of fraud, waste, and abuse in areas like tax collection, healthcare claims, and government benefits. AI-driven surveillance and cybersecurity tools can improve national security by identifying potential threats and vulnerabilities.

 5. Personalized Citizen Engagement

   AI enables the creation of personalized solutions for citizens, such as tailored recommendations for public benefits, healthcare, or educational programs. This can help governments better serve the needs of individual citizens, especially in diverse populations.

 6. Language and Accessibility Support

   AI can assist in breaking down language barriers by providing real-time translation services, enabling governments to communicate more effectively with citizens from different linguistic backgrounds. It can also improve accessibility for people with disabilities by automating processes like voice-to-text and text-to-speech.

 7. Predictive Analytics for Public Planning

   AI can assist in forecasting needs and potential crises by analyzing trends in areas such as healthcare, traffic management, and environmental monitoring. This allows governments to be more proactive and prepared for future challenges, such as natural disasters or public health outbreaks.

 8. Challenges and Ethical Considerations

   - Bias and Fairness: AI systems may unintentionally perpetuate bias, which can lead to unfair treatment in areas like law enforcement, social services, or immigration decisions.

   - Transparency and Accountability: Decisions made by AI systems can be opaque, raising concerns about accountability and fairness.

   - Job Displacement: The automation of tasks might lead to job losses in certain sectors, requiring government planning for workforce reskilling and employment transitions.

AI has the potential to make government operations more efficient, responsive, and citizen-centered, but it also requires careful planning, ethical considerations, and regulatory oversight to ensure equitable outcomes for all citizens.

 Scalability of AI Solutions for Government

 1. Infrastructure and Technology Readiness:

   - Governments must invest in robust technological infrastructure, such as cloud computing, data centers, and high-speed internet, to ensure AI systems can handle increasing amounts of data and users. Scalable infrastructure is key to expanding AI applications across different departments and regions.

2. Interoperability Across Departments:

   - AI solutions need to be adaptable across different government agencies and functions. Ensuring that AI systems can integrate with existing platforms and share data securely across various departments is essential for scaling solutions without duplicating efforts.

3. Automation of Routine Processes:

   - AI can scale by automating routine administrative tasks (e.g., application processing, tax assessments) across various departments. This leads to greater efficiency and allows government personnel to focus on complex or strategic tasks.

4. AI-Driven Public Services:

   - Scalable AI systems can handle growing demands in citizen services, such as chatbots managing high volumes of inquiries or predictive algorithms streamlining resource allocation in social services. AI tools must be flexible enough to expand based on population growth or evolving public service needs.

5. Policy and Regulation Challenges:

   - Scaling AI in government requires policies that support innovation while protecting citizen data and ensuring fairness. Governments need to establish standardized AI governance frameworks to monitor scalability across different levels of the public sector.

6. Training and Skill Development:

   - A scalable AI implementation depends on developing human capital. Governments must invest in training programs for employees to work with AI tools, ensuring that both technical staff and public service workers are capable of managing and maintaining scalable AI systems.

 Sustainability of AI Solutions for Government

 1. Energy Consumption and Environmental Impact:

   - AI systems, particularly those based on machine learning, can be energy-intensive. Governments need to adopt energy-efficient algorithms, use green data centers, and consider renewable energy sources to power their AI infrastructure, reducing the environmental impact of AI solutions.

2. Long-Term Cost Efficiency:

   - While AI requires significant initial investment in infrastructure, data collection, and system development, the long-term benefits can outweigh these costs through automation, reduced labor requirements, and more efficient public service delivery. Governments must plan for sustainable financial models that support the ongoing development and maintenance of AI systems.

3. Adaptability to Evolving Needs:

   - AI solutions must be designed to evolve with the changing needs of governments and citizens. Sustainable AI implementations require continuous updates, improvement, and adaptability to new challenges, such as emerging public health crises, economic changes, or environmental threats.

4. Ethical and Responsible AI Use:

   - For AI to be sustainable, it must operate within ethical guidelines that protect citizens' privacy, reduce biases, and ensure transparency. Governments must develop frameworks for responsible AI use, including regular audits, public consultations, and transparent reporting to maintain trust in AI systems.

5. Data Governance and Privacy:

   - Sustainable AI requires a strong focus on data governance, ensuring that citizen data is protected while AI systems process it efficiently. Governments need to ensure long-term sustainability by establishing clear data privacy policies, secure data management systems, and compliance with legal standards (e.g., GDPR or local privacy laws).

6. Collaboration with the Private Sector and Academia:

   - To maintain sustainability, governments should collaborate with private technology companies and academic institutions for continuous research and development in AI. Public-private partnerships can help share resources, reduce costs, and accelerate innovation while ensuring AI solutions remain cutting-edge and relevant.

7. Social and Workforce Impact:

   - Sustainable AI in government must consider its societal impact, particularly with regard to workforce displacement. Governments must develop strategies for reskilling workers affected by automation and ensure that AI implementation leads to positive social outcomes, such as improved quality of life and equitable access to services.

For AI solutions to be scalable and sustainable in government, they must balance efficiency, adaptability, and ethical considerations. This includes investing in technology infrastructure, developing human resources, fostering cross-departmental collaboration, managing energy consumption, and ensuring responsible AI governance to meet the long-term needs of both governments and their citizens.

 Data Management and Privacy

  1. Data Collection and Usage:

   - Transparency: Government agencies must clearly communicate what data is being collected, how it will be used, and for what purpose. Data collection should be limited to what is necessary for the specific AI application.

   - Consent: Ensure that citizens are aware of and give consent before their data is collected. For sensitive data, such as health or financial information, explicit consent must be obtained.

   - Minimization: Collect only the minimum amount of data necessary to achieve the objectives of the AI solution, reducing the risk of over-collection and misuse.

 2. Data Storage and Security:

   - Encryption: All data collected and stored by AI systems should be encrypted both at rest and during transmission to prevent unauthorized access.

   - Access Control: Implement strict access controls to ensure that only authorized personnel can view or modify sensitive data. Access should be based on the principle of least privilege, with regular audits of access logs.

   - Data Localization: For sensitive government or citizen data, it may be necessary to store data within national borders to comply with local laws and regulations.

 3. Data Anonymization and De-identification:

   - Anonymization: Personal data used in AI models must be anonymized wherever possible, especially when used for large-scale analysis or decision-making. This reduces the risk of identifying individuals from the data.

   - De-identification: For data that needs to be retained for long-term use, de-identification techniques (e.g., removing personal identifiers) should be applied to protect individual privacy while maintaining the usefulness of the data.

 4. Data Sharing and Collaboration:

   - Third-Party Agreements: When sharing data with third-party vendors or AI solution providers, governments must ensure that robust data-sharing agreements are in place. These agreements should specify data protection requirements, usage limits, and compliance with local regulations.

   - Data Sharing for Public Benefit: Any sharing of government-collected data with other entities (e.g., research organizations) must prioritize the public interest, and data shared must be anonymized or aggregated to protect privacy.

 5. Privacy Protection:

   - Data Privacy Laws Compliance: AI systems in government must comply with existing privacy laws and regulations, such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) or national data protection acts. These laws mandate that citizens have control over their personal data, including rights to access, correction, and deletion.

   - Privacy by Design: AI solutions should integrate privacy protections from the outset, incorporating privacy-preserving techniques (e.g., differential privacy) in their architecture and design.

   - Citizen Rights: Ensure that citizens have the right to know how their data is being used, the ability to request access to their data, and the option to have their data corrected or deleted from government databases.

 6. Data Governance and Audits:

   - Data Governance Framework: Establish a formal governance framework to oversee the management of AI data across all departments. This framework should include policies on data quality, lifecycle management, and data stewardship.

   - Regular Audits: Conduct regular audits of AI systems to ensure compliance with data management and privacy policies. These audits should assess security controls, data usage, and adherence to privacy regulations.

 7. Data Retention and Disposal:

   - Retention Periods: Define clear retention periods for all types of data collected by AI systems. Once the data is no longer needed for its original purpose, it should be securely deleted.

   - Secure Disposal: Implement secure data disposal practices, including the permanent erasure of data from all systems to prevent unauthorized recovery of sensitive information.

 8. Incident Response and Breach Notification:

   - Incident Response Plan: Governments must have a robust incident response plan in place to address any data breaches or unauthorized access. This plan should outline the steps to contain and mitigate the breach, assess the impact, and notify affected citizens.

   - Breach Notification: In the event of a data breach involving citizens’ personal data, governments are required to notify affected individuals promptly, outlining the nature of the breach, its potential impact, and any steps taken to protect their data.

A comprehensive data management and privacy policy ensures that government AI solutions handle citizen data responsibly, comply with relevant privacy laws, and build trust with the public. By enforcing strict data security measures, anonymization practices, and privacy rights, governments can maximize the benefits of AI while protecting the privacy and security of their citizens.

Compliance with Responsible AI Principles

To ensure that AI solutions used in government are aligned with ethical standards and societal expectations, compliance with Responsible AI principles is critical. These principles promote fairness, transparency, accountability, and ethical decision-making, safeguarding both citizen rights and public trust.

 1. Fairness and Non-Discrimination:

   - Bias Mitigation: AI systems must be designed to detect and mitigate biases in data and algorithms that could lead to unfair treatment of specific groups based on race, gender, age, or other characteristics. Regular audits should be conducted to evaluate bias in decision-making processes.

   - Inclusive Design: AI models must be trained on diverse datasets representing various demographic groups to ensure they provide fair and equitable outcomes for all citizens.

   - Equal Access: AI-driven public services must be equally accessible to all citizens, regardless of their socio-economic status, geographical location, or technological proficiency.

 2. Transparency and Explainability:

   - Transparent Decision-Making: Government AI systems should provide clear explanations of how decisions are made, particularly in high-stakes areas such as healthcare, law enforcement, and public benefits. Citizens must be able to understand the rationale behind AI-driven decisions that affect them.

   - Explainable AI: Ensure that AI models are designed with explainability in mind. Governments should be able to provide transparent and interpretable outputs, especially in areas where automated decisions could have significant impacts on individuals.

   - Public Communication: Governments must communicate openly with the public about how AI systems are being used, what data is being collected, and what safeguards are in place to protect citizen rights.

 3. Accountability:

   - Human Oversight: AI systems must include mechanisms for human oversight, particularly for critical decisions affecting citizens’ rights, freedoms, or well-being. A "human-in-the-loop" approach should be implemented to ensure AI decisions can be reviewed and corrected when necessary.

   - Clear Accountability: Establish clear lines of accountability for AI systems, assigning responsibility to specific departments or individuals for ensuring that AI models operate ethically and within legal guidelines.

   - Grievance Redress Mechanisms: Provide citizens with a clear process to challenge or appeal AI-driven decisions. Governments must ensure that errors or unfair outcomes can be rectified through human intervention.

 4. Ethical Use of Data:

   - Data Privacy Protections: Ensure that citizen data is handled responsibly, in line with privacy regulations and ethical data usage practices. AI systems should adhere to privacy-by-design principles, incorporating privacy safeguards from the outset.

   - Minimization of Harm: AI systems must be carefully evaluated to ensure they do not cause harm, such as infringing on privacy, promoting inequality, or compromising personal freedoms. Ethical risk assessments should be performed to identify potential harms before deployment.

   - Prohibited Uses: Certain AI applications, such as those that violate human rights, should be prohibited. Governments should adopt policies that prevent AI from being used for harmful or unethical purposes.

 5. Safety and Security:

   - Robustness of AI Systems: AI solutions used in government must be rigorously tested for safety, accuracy, and reliability. This includes implementing safeguards against adversarial attacks and ensuring the systems operate as intended in real-world environments.

   - Data Security: Ensure that all AI systems follow stringent cybersecurity protocols to protect sensitive citizen data from unauthorized access, breaches, or misuse. Regular security audits and updates must be performed to maintain the integrity of AI systems.

 6. Inclusivity and Accessibility:

   - Equitable Access to AI Services: AI solutions should be accessible to all citizens, including marginalized communities and individuals with disabilities. Governments must provide alternative methods for citizens to engage with AI services if they are not comfortable with or do not have access to the required technology.

   - Language and Cultural Sensitivity: AI systems should accommodate the linguistic and cultural diversity of the population, offering support for multiple languages and cultural contexts to ensure all citizens can benefit from AI-driven public services.

 7. Continuous Monitoring and Improvement:

   - Ongoing Evaluation: AI systems must be continuously monitored and updated to ensure they operate in line with Responsible AI principles. Regular assessments of system performance, fairness, and ethical impact are critical for maintaining compliance.

   - Feedback Loops: Governments should actively collect feedback from citizens and public service employees who interact with AI systems, using this input to identify areas for improvement and to make necessary adjustments to algorithms or policies.

   - Adaptability: AI systems must be adaptable to changing societal values, legal requirements, and technological advancements. This requires continuous re-evaluation of AI models to ensure they remain ethical and responsible over time.

 8. Environmental and Social Responsibility:

   - Sustainable AI Practices: Governments should prioritize the use of energy-efficient AI algorithms and sustainable data management practices. The environmental impact of AI systems must be minimized by optimizing computational resources and reducing energy consumption.

   - Social Impact Considerations: The broader social implications of AI deployment in government must be considered, ensuring that AI technologies improve social welfare, reduce inequality, and promote inclusive growth.

To comply with Responsible AI principles, government AI solutions must prioritize fairness, transparency, accountability, privacy, and inclusivity. This requires robust frameworks for bias detection, ethical data usage, citizen engagement, human oversight, and continuous monitoring. By adhering to these principles, governments can build AI systems that not only improve efficiency but also maintain public trust and promote social good.

 key technical hurdles

Implementing AI solutions in government faces several key technical hurdles due to the complexity, scale, and sensitivity of public sector operations. These challenges include issues with data handling, infrastructure, ethics, integration, and compliance with legal and regulatory frameworks.

 1. Data Quality and Availability:

   - Data Silos: Government data is often stored in disconnected systems across different agencies, making it difficult to integrate and leverage AI models. Overcoming data silos and ensuring interoperability between systems is a critical challenge.

   - Data Quality: Many government datasets may be incomplete, outdated, or inconsistent. Cleaning and pre-processing these datasets, as well as developing methods to handle missing or poor-quality data, are essential technical hurdles.

   - Sensitive Data Handling: Government data often includes sensitive information (e.g., healthcare records, criminal records, or tax data). Ensuring proper anonymization, encryption, and compliance with privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA) while using AI models is technically complex.

 2. Scalability and Infrastructure:

   - Computing Resources: AI solutions for government agencies often require large-scale data processing and storage capabilities. This demands significant investment in infrastructure such as high-performance computing (HPC) and cloud-based solutions to handle the large volumes of data.

   - Distributed AI Systems: Many AI applications in government (e.g., national security, healthcare) must operate at large scales across regions and agencies, requiring distributed AI architectures that can process data efficiently in real-time.

   - Edge Computing: In some cases, AI systems need to run at the edge, where data is generated (e.g., smart city sensors, traffic monitoring systems), but developing edge AI systems that can run efficiently with limited computational resources is a challenge.

 3. Bias, Fairness, and Ethics:

   - Bias Detection and Mitigation: Government decisions affect diverse populations, and AI systems must ensure fairness across demographics. Developing bias detection tools and debiasing algorithms is challenging, especially when historical government data contains inherent biases.

   - Ethical AI Frameworks: Governments need to ensure that AI models comply with ethical guidelines, such as fairness, transparency, and accountability. Creating technical frameworks to audit AI systems, ensure fairness, and provide transparency in decision-making is essential but complex.

   - Public Trust: AI systems must be explainable and transparent to maintain public trust. Developing interpretable models that provide understandable explanations of AI-driven decisions while ensuring model performance is a significant technical hurdle.

 4. Data Privacy and Security:

   - Data Privacy Concerns: Governments handle highly sensitive citizen data. AI systems must protect this data while ensuring compliance with legal and privacy regulations. Developing privacy-preserving AI techniques, such as differential privacy or homomorphic encryption, is challenging but necessary for responsible AI use.

   - Cybersecurity: AI systems in government are potential targets for cyberattacks. Ensuring that AI solutions are resilient to adversarial attacks and implementing strong cybersecurity measures to protect data and models from breaches or manipulation is critical.

 5. Integration with Legacy Systems:

   - Legacy System Compatibility: Many government agencies still rely on legacy systems and outdated technology. Integrating modern AI solutions with these systems is difficult due to compatibility issues and the complexity of migrating data or updating systems.

   - API Development and Standardization: Developing APIs to connect AI systems with existing platforms while ensuring data exchange between different government departments is technically demanding and requires robust standardization.

 6. Explainability and Accountability:

   - Model Interpretability: Government decisions based on AI need to be explainable, especially in areas like healthcare, law enforcement, and welfare. Developing interpretable AI models that maintain high accuracy while providing understandable explanations of decisions is a key technical hurdle.

   - Human-in-the-loop Systems: In many government applications, AI systems must involve human oversight. Developing seamless human-in-the-loop mechanisms where humans can interact with, monitor, and override AI systems when necessary requires advanced design and engineering.

 7. AI Model Deployment and Maintenance:

   - Model Drift and Updating: AI models need continuous updating as government policies, societal conditions, and data evolve. Developing systems that detect model drift and enable smooth updates without significant downtime is a major technical challenge.

   - Model Validation and Testing: AI systems in government must undergo rigorous validation and testing to ensure they meet performance, fairness, and security criteria. Setting up robust testing environments and validation processes across different departments is complex.

 8. Legal and Regulatory Compliance:

   - Regulatory Compliance: Government AI systems must comply with local and international regulations. Ensuring AI solutions adhere to data privacy laws, anti-discrimination laws, and sector-specific regulations (e.g., healthcare, finance) requires designing systems that can adjust dynamically to changing regulatory landscapes.

   - AI Auditing and Governance: Developing technical mechanisms for auditing AI systems to ensure they operate within ethical and legal guidelines is essential. This includes building frameworks to monitor, log, and review AI decisions regularly.

 9. Workforce Skills and Change Management:

   - Lack of AI Expertise: Governments often face a shortage of AI and data science talent. Implementing AI solutions requires building internal expertise or working with external partners, which adds complexity to the deployment and long-term maintenance of AI systems.

   - Change Management: Transitioning government processes to AI-based solutions requires comprehensive change management to ensure employees adapt to new technologies and systems. Developing training programs and providing technical support for government employees is a key challenge.

To successfully implement AI solutions in government, several technical challenges must be overcome, including handling large-scale data securely, ensuring fairness, integrating with legacy systems, and maintaining compliance with regulations. Addressing these hurdles requires significant investment in infrastructure, skilled talent, and the development of responsible and scalable AI systems tailored to the public sector.

 technical standards

When implementing AI solutions for the government, aligning with existing or emerging technical standards is essential to ensure safety, fairness, interoperability, and accountability. These standards provide frameworks and guidelines to support responsible and ethical AI deployment in the public sector. Some key AI standards relevant to government applications include:

 1. ISO/IEC 22989 – AI Concepts and Terminology:

   - Relevance: ISO/IEC 22989 is an international standard that defines key terms and concepts in AI, ensuring consistency across various AI systems used by government agencies. This helps standardize communication, development, and implementation of AI models, facilitating interoperability and understanding across departments.

   - Application: Governments can adopt this standard to ensure that all stakeholders (from technical teams to policymakers) are aligned on AI terminology and concepts, promoting efficient collaboration and clearer decision-making.

 2. ISO/IEC 23053 – Framework for AI Systems Using Machine Learning:

   - Relevance: This standard provides a framework for developing, deploying, and managing AI systems that use machine learning (ML) techniques. It outlines best practices for model training, testing, deployment, and maintenance, which is critical for government AI systems that require ongoing updates.

   - Application: Governments can follow this standard to build robust AI models, ensuring they are scalable, reliable, and adaptive to changing policies or public needs.

 3. NIST AI Risk Management Framework (AI RMF):

   - Relevance: The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) AI Risk Management Framework provides guidance for identifying and managing risks associated with AI technologies. It emphasizes fairness, transparency, accountability, and security, which are essential for responsible AI use in government.

   - Application: Government agencies can use this framework to assess the risks involved in deploying AI solutions, particularly those that affect citizens directly, such as in healthcare, public safety, or social services. This helps ensure that AI applications minimize harm, avoid bias, and comply with ethical guidelines.

 4. IEEE 7000 Series – Ethical AI Standards:

   - Relevance: The IEEE 7000 series focuses on ethical considerations in AI, including human rights, transparency, and accountability. These standards emphasize the importance of building AI systems that are trustworthy, human-centered, and aligned with societal values.

   - Application: Governments can adopt IEEE 7000 standards to ensure their AI systems are built and operated ethically, particularly in high-stakes areas such as law enforcement, taxation, and healthcare. These standards help ensure public trust in government AI systems by enforcing ethical AI practices.

 5. ISO/IEC 24029 – AI Bias and Transparency:

   - Relevance: ISO/IEC 24029 provides guidelines for assessing the robustness and accuracy of AI systems, including methods for detecting and mitigating bias. It also emphasizes transparency, ensuring that AI decisions can be explained and understood by stakeholders.

   - Application: Government AI systems must be transparent, particularly when making decisions that impact citizens' lives. This standard helps ensure that AI systems are fair, bias-free, and explainable, thus building trust and ensuring equitable service delivery.

 6. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and AI Compliance:

   - Relevance: The GDPR is a legal standard that governs the use of personal data in the European Union. It includes provisions on how AI systems must handle sensitive data, ensuring that citizens’ privacy is protected. AI systems need to be designed with privacy-by-design principles to comply with GDPR.

   - Application: Governments that implement AI solutions involving citizen data must ensure compliance with GDPR (or equivalent local regulations). This requires developing privacy-preserving AI techniques, such as data anonymization, differential privacy, and secure data storage practices.

 7. ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 42 – Artificial Intelligence:

   - Relevance: The ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 42 is a comprehensive international standard focused on AI and its implications, including trustworthiness, governance, and the ethical use of AI systems. It provides a broad framework for developing AI applications across different sectors, including government.

   - Application: Governments can adopt this standard to ensure their AI systems adhere to global best practices for governance, risk management, and ethical use. This helps in creating AI solutions that are not only effective but also aligned with international norms and standards.

 8. Trustworthy AI Standards by the European Commission:

   - Relevance: The European Commission’s guidelines for Trustworthy AI set principles for AI systems that are lawful, ethical, and robust. They focus on ensuring transparency, privacy, fairness, and accountability in AI systems, especially those used by public institutions.

   - Application: Government agencies, particularly in Europe, can adopt these principles when implementing AI solutions. Trustworthy AI standards guide the responsible development of AI systems that respect fundamental rights and ensure public safety.

 9. Open Data Standards for AI (e.g., W3C, Open Data Institute):

   - Relevance: Open data standards from organizations like W3C and the Open Data Institute ensure that government data, when used for AI, is standardized, interoperable, and open where appropriate. This is crucial for transparency and public engagement.

   - Application: Governments can leverage open data standards to improve the accessibility and interoperability of data used by AI systems. This facilitates collaboration between departments and ensures transparency, enabling citizens to understand how their data is used in AI systems.

 10. AI Auditing and Accountability Standards:

   - Relevance: Emerging standards around AI auditing and accountability focus on ensuring that AI systems are regularly evaluated for compliance with ethical and legal standards. These audits verify that AI systems operate as intended and are free from unintended biases or security vulnerabilities.

   - Application: Governments must regularly audit AI systems to ensure they remain compliant with ethical and legal standards. These auditing practices can help identify any biases, inefficiencies, or ethical risks, leading to necessary adjustments in AI systems to maintain trustworthiness.

Aligning AI solutions for the government with existing and emerging technical standards is essential for ensuring ethical, transparent, and secure AI systems. These standards guide the development, deployment, and ongoing operation of AI systems in the public sector, ensuring they remain accountable, fair, and reliable. By adhering to these standards, governments can ensure public trust in AI technologies and promote responsible innovation across public services.